Meet the New Voice of Baseball

LOS ANGELES — The basketball game was postponed in the morning, meaning Joe Davis would not be on the air in the afternoon. This was in January in Ann Arbor, Mich., not far from his childhood home, but Davis kept his evening flight and headed early to the airport. If he could not call a game, why pass up a free day to study?

In two months, Davis would get the job of his dreams: the lead play-by-play voice for baseball on Fox, replacing Joe Buck, who left for ESPN. Buck has called the last 20 All-Star Games, but on Tuesday at Dodger Stadium, Davis gets the assignment. He’ll be the lead voice for the World Series, too.

Davis, 34, has never been to an All-Star Game and has never worked the World Series. But it is safe to assume that nobody, at any age, has prepared more diligently for the chance. That afternoon at the airport lounge in Detroit, Davis watched four baseball broadcasts on his iPad — regular season and World Series, Buck and Vin Scully and Al Michaels.

He took notes, longhand on lined paper, as if he were still a student at Beloit College in Wisconsin preparing for a test:

“Never oversells — good to remember.”

“He was masterful, but he was masterful in ordinary ways, ways that I know how to execute: preparation, energy, curiosity, command.”

“Botched it! In Game 7! Great reminder not to be too hard on myself on mistakes.”

Davis has not made many on his path to filling the chairs of industry titans. He has been the full-time television voice of the Dodgers since Scully retired after the 2016 season, his 67th with the team. Now he takes over at Fox for Buck, who called the World Series 24 times, more than twice as many as any other television play-by-play man.

Davis, second from right, joined the Dodgers broadcast team ahead of the 2016 season, working with, left to right, Orel Hershiser, Vin Scully and Nomar Garciaparra. When Scully retired, Davis took over the lead job.Credit…Mark J. Terrill/Associated Press

“I don’t think there will ever be another scenario where you replace someone like Vin Scully, and then you replace someone like Joe Buck,” said the Hall of Fame pitcher John Smoltz, Fox’s lead baseball analyst. “So that’s not going to bother or scare him.”

Buck prepared for a broadcasting job all his life, tagging along at work with his father, Jack Buck, the Hall of Fame voice of the St. Louis Cardinals. Davis is the son of a high school football coach and, naturally, played quarterback through college. But he knew by eight years old that his future would be in the booth.

That was in 1996, when Gary Thorne enthralled Davis with a commanding voice that seemed to elevate the majesty of the Stanley Cup finals on ESPN. It was also Buck’s first year calling the World Series, and Davis can readily recite some of his memorable calls through the years.

“It’s just amazing, the little wrinkles he’s always ready for, and it never feels scripted from him,” Davis said of Buck. “When the moment happens, he captions it and captures it and gets out of the way.”

The best broadcasters make their mark with both words and silence; Scully said nothing for more than three minutes after Ray Knight rumbled home on Bill Buckner’s error to end Game 6 of the 1986 World Series. When the Fox Sports executive Brad Zager first heard Davis’s work, about a decade ago, he noticed Davis’s nuanced understanding of the craft.

“There were two things: the actual tone of his voice, the cadence and all that, but also I was caught off guard by a young broadcaster who actually wasn’t over-talking,” Zager said. “He wasn’t being over-descriptive. With the college basketball reel I was watching, he was laying out on a big 3-pointer and letting the crowd be part of the broadcast. That’s stuff you usually teach to people as they grow in this business and do bigger events — let the moment breathe, don’t try to be the star — and he had it naturally. He was a student of the game.”

If Davis sounded like a natural, those studies had a lot to do with it. By knowing precisely what he wanted to be at a young age, he could plan a route to get there. Recruited for football by schools like Harvard, Brown and Amherst College, he chose Beloit largely for the broadcasting reps; after the fall season, he was free to do all the play-by-play he wanted, right away, for the basketball and baseball teams.

In the classroom, Davis took an independent-study course on voice with a theater instructor. In the dorm, he applied the lessons.

To prepare for his elevated role, Davis studied the work of Scully and Joe Buck, the two men he has been asked to replace. Credit…Kyle Grillot for The New York Times

“We’d go out on a Friday night, have a good time, a couple of beers, and there was Joe up in his room, watching baseball on YouTube, recording himself calling the game,” said Rick Krajewski, a college friend who now works in the booth with Davis. “We’d be like, ‘Hey, Joe, come on, let’s do something fun.’ And it was: ‘Nope, sorry guys, gotta do this.’”

Before his senior year, Davis landed a summer job at the microphone of the independent Schaumburg Flyers in Illinois. After graduating in 2010, he worked three seasons as the voice of the Montgomery Biscuits, the Class AA affiliate of the Tampa Bay Rays. After games, he would listen to his broadcasts and transcribe some parts; studying his words made him more concise.

By then, Davis had a network of colleagues to advise him — if only they could think of something to say. Joe Block, now a broadcaster for the Pittsburgh Pirates, was working in the minors and running a website for job postings when he first heard Davis’s work. The kid was a can’t-miss prospect.

“It was ridiculous, just so polished and so good,” Block said. “The résumé said he was 19 years old, and we were astonished. We got in touch and I said, ‘I’ve got nothing for you, please remember me,’ something like that.”

Davis moved to ESPN in 2012 and to Fox two years later, adding a role with the Dodgers in 2015 and developing a rapport with the former pitcher Orel Hershiser, his regular partner on their telecasts. Along the way, Davis met Buck, who offered perspective on their profession: “If you get hit by a bus on your way to the stadium, they’re not going to hold a moment of silence for you.” Take the job seriously, in other words, but don’t carry yourself that way.

“You’ve done all that work and your chest is puffed up and you’ve got your best suit on and your best tie knot — and nobody cares,” Buck said. “They’re there to watch the game. So be able to laugh at yourself, be willing to not try to cram 30 pounds of stuff into a 10-pound bag. You have to be your own best editor and your own harshest editor.”

Calling the All-Star Game, Buck said, was always his most challenging night of the year. Frequent substitutions are tricky enough, but now players wear All-Star uniforms instead of their team’s colors, removing a big visual clue. The pacing of the game is also quicker than usual, with hitters more eager to swing than to work the count. That leaves less time to fit individual narratives into the broadcast.

Davis will highlight some statistics, but he makes sure not to let a broadcast turn into math class. Credit…Kyle Grillot for The New York Times

Davis likes weaving in stories, partly because Scully did it so well and he knew his Dodger audience would expect it, but also because it just makes for good television. Davis read books last winter on story structure, sharpening his delivery of the copious notes and nuggets he sorts into files on his phone and tablet.

“I’m interested to kind of see how it feels telling some of these stories in the World Series and in these huge games because you never want to get in the way of the next pitch,” Davis said. “Every next pitch can be the pitch.”

Davis, who is married with three young children, leans on Krajewski for statistics, mainly to spot trends and give context to the data. On a recent telecast in Cincinnati, Davis pointed out that the Reds’ Donovan Solano goes by “Donnie Barrels” because he hits line drives at a very high rate. No need to cite the specific figure and compare it to the norm.

“I have never given a barrel percentage,” Davis said. “I don’t want to turn it into math class.”

On Tuesday, before he inks the first box in the All-Star score book Buck passed down to him, Davis will introduce each of the players over the public-address system at Dodger Stadium. That will make Davis the master of ceremonies, of sorts, for baseball’s summer showcase and affirm his rise to the heady position Zager gave him four months ago.

“I’m here,” Zager said then, “to offer you a chance to be the voice of baseball.”

Back to top button